In the last issue I discussed how impossible it is to predict the future, whether in life as a general proposition, or for what the tax laws may become. In this issue I shall explore the question: is the future predetermined, for our free will to decide, or, subject to the whims of chance and blind fate? Why do some get into trouble with the IRS yet others completely avoid contact with that dreaded agency?
OPENING DOORS: WHAT HAPPENS TO US?
Not only is our death predetermined, but many believe our life in a broad sense is predetermined by unfinished business of the soul. Some call it Karma. We assume physical form and life presents us with needed learning opportunities. During life’s passage, we come upon many doors that can be entered or not. Our destiny is in our hands to the extent we may choose among these doorways. The choices determine what happens thereafter and for many in the hereafter.
Others believe in fatalism, that it is pure chance or blind fate which determines life’s direction, or, as Daniel Defoe said, “The best of men cannot suspend their fate. The good die early and the bad die late.” The epic poem Beowulf is steeped in the notion that life is uncontrollable and death randomly picks its victims. Sophocles’ “Oedipus Rex” could not escape his inevitable destiny. Others like William Jennings Bryan argued that “Destiny is not a matter of chance, it is a matter of choice; it is not a thing to be waited for, it is a thing to be achieved.”
In Thornton Wilder’s classic novel “The Bridge of San Luis Rey” a friar witnesses the collapse of an Inca woven rope bridge traversed by hundreds every day, flinging five people to their deaths. “Why did this happen to those five?” The friar decides to investigate whether something in each lost life had predetermined his or her fate. Did the victims die from God’s retribution for some committed wrong or was blind fate at work? He thinks, “If there were any plan in the ...
Read More »